14 user reviews
Get preloved baby clothes chosen by passionate stylists and parents who want to make clothes shopping easier for moms and dads alike.

Quantity

Shipping

Frequency

Price

  7

  5-10 Days

  Once Monthly

  $19.99 / $39.99 / $64.99

We just subscribed to PICKYBUNNY.com last month. The site says Preloved baby clothing club, but they have clothes from newborn up to 5T. So far they have been awesome! All 7 clothes we received for our LO was in excellent condition, and $$$ name brands. My husband and I love the idea that we get a personal baby stylist, getting the brands we want without dealing with eBay or Craigslist unreliable sellers. They are also Eco-friendly, and constantly have deals on their Facebook page. Wish I’ve waited, but they have a 50% deal going on right now! I think they are going to start buying in clothes in August. Which is great, since I need an outlet for my baby clothes addiction. =)

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: -1 (from 3 votes)
Jackie
July 29, 2012
5:04 am
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I have tried 3 baby clothing subscription boxes so far. I’m slightly addicted. I was pleased to find PickyBunny because they offer quality, gently-loved clothing and I do feel guilty sometimes with the amount of baby clothes I purchase that my 6 month old quickly grows out of. I tried the Trial Box offer and they provide 7 clothing items from all 3 levels of their clothing selections. That’s another nice feature – that you can select from 3 different plans (haven’t seen anyone else offer this!). There’s Budget, Basic & Boutique. I’d love to subscribe to the Boutique plan but I think my husband would kill me. Any how, the trial box was great! I wish I could subscribe to the trial box & receive clothes from all 3 levels! We received our 7 items and I love them all. They took into consideration that we live in Florida and its HOT and everything we received is great for our weather. They mailed out the trial box faster than I expected. Like I mentioned, this is the 3rd baby clothing subscription that I’ve tried and I was definitely impressed. I signed on for a monthly subscription after loving our trial box (they offer specials on their website). I’d definitely recommend them to friends.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Liz Olivier
August 4, 2012
1:44 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

We received our first Pickybunny shipment today, the trial box which includes 7 items (3 Budget, 3 Basic & 1 Boutique). The box included two onesies (Child of Mine), two dresses w/diaper covers (Carter’s & Child of Mine) and one romper (Polo). My total was $28 (trial box plus TN tax which included free shipping) and the size I chose was 0-3 months for my 8 week old, 10 pound baby girl.
Here is how I graded our box:
Style: A+. The stylist nailed my style to a “T”. I asked for florals, polka dots & ruffles and each item suited my daughter’s clothing style perfectly. Very cute!
Customer Service: A. The store owner included a handwritten note which I thought was a nice touch. The shipment arrived within a week of ordering and shipping was free (a $9 value).
Impression of clothing items: C-. The clothes overall were nice, though nothing special. They were folded neatly by outfit, smelled fresh like they were washed in Dreft baby detergent and the onesies were snapped. Two of the items were, in my opinion, a lot more than “gently used”. The fabric of one onesie was very faded and both had a lot of pilling (like they had been washed and passed down through several children). These items are going straight to GoodWill. The Boutique romper is too small for my 8 week old baby to wear. I was also a bit surprised to find that two diaper covers were thought of as 2 of the 7 items, which means we actually only got 5 items of clothing for our baby. That seems a bit shady because you cannot mix + match diaper covers with other clothes like you can for an actual set (pants & a shirt or a shorts set). So out of 7 total “items”, 1 is too small for my baby to wear, 2 are worn/faded and are being donated, 2 are diaper covers which means only 2 items in the entire box are actually useable for daily wear. I want to be clear in that I was not expecting items that had only been worn once and still had that “new” look, I knew exactly what I was purchasing: used clothing. However; from the description on the website and the name “Pickybunny” I was led to believe the items would be consignment quality.
Comments: If you decide to try Pickybunny for your child, I would definitely recommend that you purchase clothing a size larger than your little one currently wears, since previous washes will cause the clothing to have shrunk. I believe that most parents (& certainly myself) would expect “gently used clothing” to be just that, nice-looking items you would find at an upscale consignment store, not items that you would pick up at a yard sale for .25- .50. I don’t feel like I received my money’s worth’ for $28. After paying tax & shipping (because we all know that the shipping cost is included in the actual price we pay) the clothing would be a retail value of $16, which means the store owner would have had to find items under half of that to actually make money on the boxes. You tell me if 7 clothing items for $8 are going to include gently used consignment quality items.
$28 cost of box
- $9 shipping
- $3 tax
=$16 retail cost of clothes
And although I hate to say it, since the Basic box is priced at $29.99, you will be paying even more. Consider subscribing to Wittlebee, where at least your items are brand-new. Their customer service is very slow to respond to your requests by email, phone service non-existent and shipments take 2-3 weeks but at least you get your money’s worth with free shipping.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: +4 (from 6 votes)
M78
August 9, 2012
9:20 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I was not impressed at all with PickyBunny. I had really high hopes for this service, but was greatly disappointed. After leaving detailed notes for a box for my 9 month old girl I received 4 items that were actually for boys and my “boutique” item was a very worn, pilled, and faded onesie that was very poor quality and the fabric was actually crunchy. I would not recommend this service for anyone. :(

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Rachel
August 16, 2012
4:14 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I’m so in love with Pickybunny! Finally! A company that really cares about their customers. I received my bundle box last week, it includes 1 boutique, 3 basic, and 3 budget clothes for my baby. The clothes are in better condition than I expected. In fact I found the same boutique Janie and Jack dress at my resale store for $15. And with free shipping. It’s such a steal. The stylist really took my notes to heart. No cartoon character! The other items were baby Gap onesie, H&M romper, Gymboree dress for Basic clothes, and Circo jeans for the Budget item. All items would costs me probably $70 in stores. And when I emailed my stylist that I was not happy with the gap onesie, not their fault l forgot to mention that I don’t really need onesies, she offered me a replacement item in next month’s box right away and wrote in my profile “no onesies”.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Jen
August 16, 2012
8:49 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

Horrible.. Asked for Diva and bright colors and no whites. Received two white shirts, tan pants, plain red vest, jeans, pink zebra shirt, and red/green shirt. The Zebra shirt was the only thing that matched our profile. I will also use jeans and red vest. The other items were very worn. Overall I probably could have got all this for $5 at a garage sale. Lesson learned.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Nichole
August 26, 2012
2:09 pm
Total Rating:

My friend actually told me about pickybunny. I really liked the clothes she received so I signed up for the basic box. The items I got was in excellent condition. There was a little fading in one of the shirts, but it was minimum and expected from used clothes. I’m type A so I inspected everything very closely. Everything was wrapped in tissue paper. The shipping box is just a standard USPS box. It says Please reuse for USPS shipping. I guess that’s part of their whole Eco conscious thing, which is great! The stylist was also spot on. Although, since this is my first box I did call them to make sure they understand what I mean by Retro. My stylist responded to me in no time and was very helpful with the whole process. I can’t say the same for other subscription boxes, and I’ve tried them all. Needless to say I can’t wait for our next box!!

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Patricia
August 27, 2012
3:51 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

Any company who goes about deleting comments on their social media outlets are shady in my opinion. Im not impressed by this company at all. Horrible customer service.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: -1 (from 5 votes)
Tasha
September 1, 2012
9:35 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I do not like pickybunny, at all. The clothes were ok from my first month’s box. There were two shirts that had staining. But, I just thought I was being too picky about gently used clothing. My second box was worse than horrible. One pair of pants had a huge hole in the knee, the cute sweater had a hole in the sleeve, and very obvious staining on two shirts. So, out of 7 items, 4 items were unusable and only 3 could be used. My kiddo makes playclothes just fine, I don’t need to pay 29.99 a month for play clothes. Thanks but no thank you. I will stick with other boxes and gently used clothing sites.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: +1 (from 3 votes)
supertooth!
November 1, 2012
3:08 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I got some very cute clothes from here. They really paid attention to my requests and the customer service was great. Clothes were in excellent shape. Two of my items still had tags on. I prefer this service over Wittlebee. Pickybunny’s second-hand clothes are nicer than Wittlebee’s new stuff.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Jenn
November 15, 2012
4:31 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I have received two boxes so far and have been very happy with both. My style requests were fulfilled perfectly and the quality of the clothes was great. I love that I can tell my notes were actually read.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Jeanie
November 29, 2012
11:30 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I’ve been with them for 4 months now. Every month my daughter gets so excited when her box arrives. It’s really a good value for kids clothing. I’m really confused about the negative reviews here. The company really cares about their customers. They are always willing to work with you, and I can always count on a quick response. Please don’t stop what you are doing Pickybunny! We love you!

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0 (from 2 votes)
Vanessa
January 19, 2013
5:15 am
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

I ordered a trial box and I was very disappointed when I opened it up. All items appear to be washed. They do not look new at all. Also, I ordered trial box for size 2T and more than half of the items in the box are way too small. The others just look worn and have a bit of stain. I don’t know. I saw great reviews on this page. Should I give it another try? I just returned everything to them.

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: +1 (from 1 vote)
Om
January 22, 2013
7:53 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

Just got my trial box too! I was very impressed with all the items in my box. Other subscription boxes would send me summer clothes in the middle of winter…
I agree with most of the reviews here that their customer service is stellar. Pickybunny is a better choice for me. Wish they would post more pictures on their Facebook page. I just ordered their newbie bunny box for some new clothes. Can’t wait to get them!!!!

VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: +1 (from 1 vote)
Joan
January 24, 2013
9:30 pm
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating
Total Rating:

Add Your Review Required fields are marked *

Your Name (or Nickname):
Your Email Address:
Your Review:
Your Rating:
Product Quality
Presentation
Shipping Speed
Customer Service
Overall Rating

Copyright © 2012 Subscriptionbox.com - All Rights Reserved